Direct flights from New York to Key West LGA → EYW
American Airlines and Delta Air Lines fly nonstop from New York (LGA) to Key West (EYW). The flight takes about 3h and covers 1,210 miles (1,947 km). Round-trip fares typically run around $517, with recent bookable fares from $416. Arrivals run on time 67.1% at LGA and 82.5% at EYW — BTS data for the last three months, counting arrivals within 15 minutes of schedule. Fares last checked 28 August 2026.
60-day flexibility overview based on 2 recent fares across the next 60 days
Cheapest combos
American
Best
🔔 Watch LGA → EYW
We re-run this search daily and email you the moment the price drops below typical.
Free · checked daily · one-click unsubscribe
American Airlines
AA
Delta Air Lines
DL
Nonstop departures observed in recent fares
Across 2 recent dates we priced, New York (LGA) to Key West (EYW) showed up to 1 nonstop departure a day, departing around 10:13, operated by American.
10:13
Departure times seen while pricing this route over the last few weeks — a sample, not the full timetable. Airlines adjust schedules seasonally.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a direct flight from New York to Key West?
Yes, American Airlines and Delta Air Lines operate nonstop flights from New York (LGA) to Key West (EYW).
Which airlines fly direct from New York to Key West?
American Airlines, Delta Air Lines operate nonstop flights from New York to Key West.
How long is the flight from New York to Key West?
The nonstop flight from New York to Key West takes ~3h (approximately 1947 km).
What is the on-time performance for flights from New York to Key West?
Arrivals run on time 67.1% at LGA and 82.5% at EYW — BTS data for the last three months, counting arrivals within 15 minutes of schedule.
How much is a round-trip flight from New York to Key West?
Round-trip flights from New York (LGA) to Key West (EYW) start at $416, with a typical fare around $517. Based on 2 recent fare combinations.
Explore More
Scout — our search agent — hunts nonstop fares from New York every night and pings you when one's worth booking.
Watch it work →